Abraham Rhodes was my 6th-great-grandfather. Despite my research and many others, Abraham’s origins and ancestry remain a mystery.
As best as we can tell, he materialized out of thin air onto the muster rolls of the His Majesty’s 40th Regiment of Foot. He was at Staten Island on 14 July 1776, at Perth Amboy on 05 May 1777, at the Battle of Germantown on 04 October 1777 and at Philadelphia, 15 March 1778. The 40th was regularly stationed in England and Ireland before being sent to Boston to quell the rebellion in 1775. The regiment saw action in New York, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey before being sent to the West Indies in late 1778. The regiment was returned to New York in 1781 and back to England at the end of the war in 1783.
Abraham, however, did not accompany the regiment back across the Atlantic. In 1784, Abraham, as a discharged soldier under the former command of Sgt. Hugh Gillespie, received a land grant in Clements, Annapolis Co. NS. He married Mary BARTON and appears to have remained in the Annapolis Valley the rest of his life. His date of death is unknown; however, it was after 1820, when he sold his original land to his son John. About as much is known of Mary as of her husband – she appears to been from a loyalist, not a planter family, and some have suggested that she is the same Mary Barton who was born 18 February 1758 in Warwick, Kent Co. RI to Rufus and Catherine (RHODES) BARTON. The evidence for this proposition, at least that which I have seen, is non-existent. Even if we could identify Mary, it is unclear how much that would help identify Abraham, given the influx of people from across the colonies into Nova Scotia at the time; there is no reason to assume the couple knew each other before exile.
Based on the muster rolls, it appears Abraham enlisted in the 40th between June to December 1775, when the regiment was headquartered in Boston. This might suggest that he was from the area, given the presumed difficulty of crossing British lines; no-one fitting his description has been found in Massachusetts records, however.
Other evidence suggests a connection to New York. In Granville, Abraham lived in close proximity to an Anthony RHODES, who can be proven to be a loyalist from Queens Co. NY. Both families had similar given names as well (but not such unusual or exacting names that a relationship is certain). Some researchers believe Abraham enlisted in Ireland, although this would not seem to be consistent with his later loyalist land grants.
It is difficult to make any solid conclusions about Abraham’s origins at all. Given the lack of any claims for property, etc. lost in America, one would think he didn’t come from money – but that same demographic often had the most to gain from the Revolution, so this is little more then speculation. If Mary was from Rhode Island, maybe her mother and Abraham were kinsmen. Maybe more research into Anthony’s extended family might show a connection beyond geographic proximity (which also raises the question of his dedication to the King, if he did enlist in Boston). It is all very frustrating.